As Minnesota’s state demographer, Susan Brower collects and analyzes data that provides context for Minnesotans, including manufacturers, as they face the future. She has degrees from the University of Minnesota’s Humphrey School of Public Policy and the University of Michigan, where she earned a Ph.D. An astute observer of the trends that impact communities across the state, Brower relishes the opportunity to zero in on some of the most significant demographic trends, and she notes that they are mostly immovable, regardless of how we feel about them. She spoke recently about her thoughts on the persistent workforce shortage that manufacturers have wrestled with for years.
Manufacturers have faced workforce challenges for more than a decade. Do you have any insight for them about the ongoing labor shortage?
Brower: While you don’t necessarily need our data to know that the labor shortage is happening, our data can help explain why it’s happening and also point to the fact that it’s likely to be more or less permanent.
That permanence is based on data from the U.S. Census Bureau and from the American Community Survey that surveys 65,000 households each year in Minnesota. We also use birth records to get a good read on what birth rates are. We apply that to the number of people who are living in each area.
We can look at all those numbers for future decades and see that this is something that is likely to continue because of the demographic shifts that are happening.
We’re at what people in higher ed call a demographic cliff, where 2025 was the largest cohort of high school graduates coming out of Minnesota high schools, and from here on out we will have fewer graduates coming down the pipeline.
It’s likely to be more or less a permanent situation. The only question mark about whether those forecasts will materialize is what happens with immigration.
Let’s talk about immigration. What role has it played in Minnesota’s labor force, and how much could it change the outlook?
Brower: It’s hard to predict what flows of international immigration might look like in the future, especially since federal policy has been so varied over the past decade or longer. We saw between 2022 and 2024 a surge of immigration that kept labor force growth much higher than it otherwise would have been without that flow of immigrants up from the southern border of the U.S. We saw an increase in immigration in Minnesota during those years as well. So what I had been predicting in terms of slower growth has continued, but it’s been buoyed a little bit by that temporary increase in immigration.
We can look at other countries and how they’ve dealt with this issue, but there are not other ways for countries to grow their workforce other than migration or having more children. Those that have tried to impact birth rates have sometimes seen a small increase for a short period of time, but then the birth rates continue to decline.
Almost universally, immigration has been what countries have looked to as they try to counter the slowdown in growth and try to bolster the labor force. Some countries have done it on a short-term basis, like Japan. And others have had more or less unrestrictive immigration policies where people might come more permanently. I’m thinking of Germany, for example.
When it comes to the long-term decline in the labor force, I could be wrong about the permanence of it, but I think the only way that I’m wrong is if there is a substantial change in immigration policy.
Are all areas of the state, and all types of companies, affected the same way, or are some regions and businesses bucking the trend?
Brower: It’s more acute in some areas of Greater Minnesota, particularly in the north. You’re even seeing a shrinking labor force rather than a slower-growing labor force. We don’t expect a lot of growth for much of Greater Minnesota, and we expect slower growth in the metro areas than we’ve seen in past decades.
For manufacturers, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to be that their growth will slow or that they won’t be able to find workers, but this is the context that they’ll be operating in. And so that part is certain. What they do in response, or how they recruit, or how they focus on their markets — those will be the decisions that they have to make as they align with this reality.
What steps can manufacturers take to improve their chances of maintaining a robust workforce?
Brower: Usually economic growth slows as labor force growth slows. I’m not an economist, but I dabble in it because of what I do. One possibility for manufacturers is to increase productivity, which might mean fewer people doing more. It also might mean increasing the value of the goods and services that they’re creating. Can you be more efficient, more productive in other ways that offset those workforce slowdowns?
I also know manufacturers that have changed how they recruit. One was telling me that he’s done a lot of work with the local trade school, including adjusting the shifts that people come in so they can work around the classes that they need to take to move up. The manufacturer created pathways where they promise them that if they take those classes and if they stay in their position that they will continue to advance.
This permanent, slow-, or no-growth labor market is the context in which you have to build policies and practices. But I’m not saying that there’s nothing to be done. AI and other technologies have the potential to improve productivity in manufacturing, but we should be careful not to overstate their near-term impact. I would encourage employers to identify specific opportunities to improve efficiency and then consider whether AI or other technologies could help. Starting with the problem rather than the technology will lead to a more realistic assessment of AI’s potential.
Return to the Winter 2026 issue of Enterprise Minnesota® magazine.