We ended every State of Manufacturing® focus group this year with the question: “If you could do it all over again, would you start your business, and would you start it in Minnesota?” It was meant as a quick wrap-up. Instead, it drew some of the most eye-opening answers of each session.

Nearly every participant would start their business again. Fewer would start it here. It’s like someone who would gladly marry again … just not the same person. Their commitment to manufacturing is as strong as ever. Their confidence in Minnesota as a place to grow has slipped, and that deserves some attention.

Participants answered the first question without hesitation. The second gave them pause. Many said neighboring states now look more welcoming, and some companies weighing expansion are already comparing sites across the border. That’s useful feedback for anyone who wants that growth to happen here.

For too long, the public discourse around business leaders — including manufacturing — has cast them as adversaries of regulation rather than architects of community prosperity. Legislators sometimes speak of “corporate interests” as though they were distant, faceless entities. Our research tells a very different story.

These are people who built their companies from the ground up, often over generations, navigating recessions, supply chain disruptions, and workforce shortages along the way. They provide family-sustaining wages and benefits in both rural and urban communities, frequently serving as the largest employer in town. They partner with schools and technical colleges to build tomorrow’s workforce, funding scholarships and apprenticeship programs. They reinvest in the regions where their employees live, shop, and raise families, sponsoring youth sports teams and showing up at school board meetings. They are not obstacles to good policy. They are essential partners in it.

When the overwhelming majority of manufacturers say they would choose a different state today, that is not rhetoric — it is a competitiveness indicator. It reflects real concerns about tax structure, regulatory complexity, and workforce availability. For legislators crafting tax and other policies, educators shaping workforce pipelines, and economic developers courting new investment, this data point should inform strategy.

Ignoring this signal doesn’t make it disappear. It simply means the next expansion, the next headquarters, the next generation of good-paying jobs may land somewhere else — in Iowa, in the Dakotas, in Wisconsin — while Minnesota wonders what happened.

This is not a call for deregulation at any cost, nor a plea for special treatment. It is a call for collaboration — for policymakers, educators, and business leaders to sit at the same table and build a Minnesota where growing a manufacturing business is not an act of loyalty despite the odds, but a smart, sustainable choice.

Minnesota has real strengths to build on: a skilled workforce, strong educational institutions, and a legacy of innovation that stretches back generations. But strengths alone won’t keep manufacturers here if the cost of doing business keeps climbing relative to our neighbors. The fix doesn’t require reinventing the wheel — it requires listening to the people already invested in our state’s success and acting with urgency. Small, consistent wins on tax policy, labor mandates, permitting timelines, and workforce development can rebuild the confidence this year’s survey revealed is fraying. Minnesota doesn’t need to become a different state. It needs to become, once again, the state manufacturers choose first.

To the legislators and congressional delegation heading to St. Paul and Washington, to the educators shaping our future workforce, to the economic developers marketing our state, and to the media shaping public understanding: Minnesota’s manufacturers are not looking to leave. They are looking for a reason to stay.

That distinction matters. It should shape every conversation, every bill, and every classroom curriculum this coming year. The question is no longer whether we understand the challenge. It’s whether we’re ready to meet it — together.

Return to the Winter 2026 issue of Enterprise Minnesota® magazine.

Subscribe to Enterprise Minnesota magazine.